Atonement movie

*****

Reviewed by ManicMammy via on 09 Mar 2008

item website

I was disappointed by this film. It looked fabulous and the acting was good, especially Saoirse Ronan who plays a 13 year old who's lie dictates what happens to the main characters of Cecelia played by Keira Knightley and Robbie played by James McAvoy. I found the jumping narrative annoying. It felt like 2 movies wedged together. The first set in English country house around 1935 is more compelling and I felt the movie lost momentum when it progressed to the second world war section. Whilst the Dunkirk scene was impressive for its demonstration of the horrors of war, I felt it didn't really add much to the main story of the movie. In the end, I wasn't that concerned what happened to the characters which I may have done had more time been spent on them rather than war scenes.

Categories

2 of 2 people found this useful

Leave your comment

Leave your comment

Was this review helpful?

ManicMammy
Cork, Ireland

Quick Help

Badges? Badges?

I Love LouderVoice LV

Review writing competition

must enter LouderVoice review writing competition

Review of the day

Product image

The Dark Knight (2008)

* * * * *

Maxim

google_ad_section_start By now everyone knows that The Dark Knight (a.k.a. Batman Begins 2 ) has been a boxoffice record-setting sequel to the 2005′ Batman Begins...

read more about The Dark Knight (2008)

Review of the week

Product image

Heat (RTE)

* * * * *

reviewer188237

I've just watched the second episode. Are these people really the best that applied to be on the show? Sauages and a can of tomatoes...

read more about Heat (RTE)

Latest review

Product image

killaloe..pubs food

* * * * *

reviewer188269

Crottys Bar killaloe in Clare is great place for food and good guinness. Fish and steaks wonderful......

Latest member

reviewer188272reviewer188272

View more recent members

Latest mobile review

Product image

Mamma Mia

* * * * *

famron

A guilty pleasure. Best to dive straight in and enjoy singing along to the ABBA songs. Cast clearly had a laugh. (Though cd barely watch...

read more about Mamma Mia

Loud topics

view all categories

Lucky Dip
temple
2star
eating+out
paris
house
restaurant
united+kingdom
manor
tralee
5star
Recently online
Damien Mulley
Conor O'Neill
Catherine O'Neill
theaardvark
gem
MovieWatch
Bernard Goldbach
Louder minis
Ivory Lounge
KFC's Hot Rods
Mamma Mia
The Newsroom
Alpha Zeta 2004 'R' Valpolicella Superiore Ripasso
Guildford Arms
Cafe Royal
Prince Regent
LV Blog
Taste of Cork Competition Winner
Win a Gift Hamper for Taste of Cork Reviews
LouderVoice now supported on Profilactic
New version of LouderVoice Wordpress Plug-in
Another competition winner
Where do you review?
Here on LouderVoice
By SMS from your mobile
On your microblog
On your own blog