Celebrity Bainisteoir

*****

Reviewed by Conor O'Neill via on 31 Mar 2008

item website

This short series on RTE is a great piece of TV despite containing many of their usual mistakes. A small set of "celebrities" manage intermediate-level Gaelic Football teams in a playoff.

Myself and RTE have a basic disaggreement on what constitutes a celebrity. e.g. Some ex-Rose of Tralee who sometimes appears on The Panel does not even appear on a Z-list in my book. But to be fair they have created a reasonable mix. Two ex-politicians, two dolly birds, a comedian, some TV himbo, a journalist/famous feminist and a solicitor.

Each is given a middle-of-the-road football team in their home county to manage (Cork, Dublin, Wicklow, Wexford, Mayo, Westmeath, Derry, Limerick). Simple play-offs are held to get to a final. The show follows them as they try to manage the team (and get advice from legendary local managers).

And ye know what? It bloody works. A simple simple formula with the right combination of humour and deadly seriousness. I think I particularly like it because my GAA knowledge is desperate and it appears the same is true of all the managers. Each got a different welcome and a gave different opening pitch (pun intended). Most teams seemed to want to get "The Eyebrows" as their manager to help with motivation. Lucky Crumlin got her. As at the Golden Spiders, witty comebacks are not the girl's forte but she seems game.

I immediately liked Ivan Yates. An ex-politician who has built up a massive bookie business, he already had the odds ready going in. He told the team that the best intermediate team in Wexford probably wasn't as good as an average Cork one. I think that straight-up attitude is going to do the business for them.

All the others are entertaining in different ways. I think poor Nell has lost most of the wit that made her famous and I find her patter a bit boring and the gender nonsense is exactly that: "I've never worked exclusively with men". Yawn Nell, wrong century. I still have no idea who the Baz character is.

The teams themselves are interesting with Cork and Dublin being the obvious favourites. Both teams from very rough areas of their respective cities and Cork appearing to have more energy/aggression. The  team from Wicklow comes from a tiny village so you have to assume they are up against it.

Despite all the good-natured and fun aspects of the programme, it serves a useful purpose in showing the passion of players and fans for teams that will never make it big. I have so much more time for that than I do for the mindless support of Man U or similar.

Looking forward to the first game!

1 of 1 people found this useful

Comments

reviewer187721

reviewer187721 at 18:46 - 13 Apr, 2008 said:

im from canada and went to watch the kiltimagh game with some college friends from castlebar, had a great weekend and would recommend the games to anyone, i learned alot about football esp that its not american football, also that it is irelands national sport and deeply rooted in irelands rebel history, culture and language, sadly ice hockey cant really compare ,,,
conoroneill

Conor O'Neill at 20:03 - 13 Apr, 2008 said:

I'm looking forward to tonight's episode. Derry vs Limerick. Hard one to call.
reviewer187731

reviewer187731 at 21:53 - 16 Apr, 2008 said:

wit, is it? wit? what's so amusing about standing there, your two arms the one length, unable to help a team that might be about to crash out of the tournament... and you and your pitch cred with it . Wit , is it, ye ,,who are you, anyway?Never heard of you. LOser. love nell

Leave your comment

Leave your comment

Was this review helpful?

Conor O'Neill
Bandon, Cork, Ireland

Quick Help

Badges? Badges?

I Love LouderVoice LV

Review writing competition

must enter LouderVoice review writing competition

Review of the day

Product image

Andre Goichot Fleurie 2006

* * * * *

Julian

Good enough value at full price: rounded, balanced, pleasing Fleurie for those that enjoy lighter reds.  Brilliant value with current SuperValu offer bringing it down...

read more about Andre Goichot Fleurie 2006

Review of the week

Product image

Heat (RTE)

* * * * *

reviewer188237

I've just watched the second episode. Are these people really the best that applied to be on the show? Sauages and a can of tomatoes...

read more about Heat (RTE)

Latest review

Product image

Boom Boom (RTE)

* * * * *

Conor O'Neill

An excellent show on Irish comedy. Opens with Tommy Tiernan classic. Covered him, Podge & Rodge and Apres Match.

Latest member

reviewer188278reviewer188278

View more recent members

Latest mobile review

Product image

Mamma Mia

* * * * *

famron

A guilty pleasure. Best to dive straight in and enjoy singing along to the ABBA songs. Cast clearly had a laugh. (Though cd barely watch...

read more about Mamma Mia

Loud topics

view all categories

Lucky Dip
ireland
movie
united+kingdom
near
temple
bar
germany
&
2star
3star
Recently online
Conor O'Neill
BBQ King
Damien Mulley
Catherine O'Neill
theaardvark
gem
MovieWatch
Louder minis
Boom Boom (RTE)
Celebrity Masterchef 2008 penultimate episode
Dark Knight
Jimmy Doherty's Farming Heroes
Celebrity Masterchef 2008
Ivory Lounge
KFC's Hot Rods
Mamma Mia
LV Blog
Taste of Cork Competition Winner
Win a Gift Hamper for Taste of Cork Reviews
LouderVoice now supported on Profilactic
New version of LouderVoice Wordpress Plug-in
Another competition winner
Where do you review?
Here on LouderVoice
By SMS from your mobile
On your microblog
On your own blog